Martha Stewart Etching Cream vs Armour Etch: The Glassy Grudge Match

When it comes to DIY glass etching projects, choosing the right etching cream can make all the difference. 

Two popular contenders in this space are Martha Stewart Etching Cream VS Armour Etch." These products have garnered varying levels of acclaim from users, with each offering its unique set of advantages and disadvantages. 

In this article, we'll delve into a head-to-head comparison of Martha Stewart Etching Cream and Armour Etch, exploring the pros and cons of each to help you make an informed decision for your next creative endeavor.

Martha Stewart Etching Cream:


  • Can be used for various DIY projects, including glassware, mirrors, and glazed ceramics.
  • Easy to use - simply brush on and rinse with water to create a permanent etch.
  • Soap and water cleanup makes it convenient for users.
  • Good for creating gifts and marking dishes.
  • Some users prefer it over other brands due to its thickness and lack of dripping.


  • Effectiveness may vary on different surfaces, with some users reporting uneven results.
  • Not suitable for old glass dishes, and the effectiveness may decrease on certain types of glass.
  • Some users experienced splotchy or inconsistent etching results.
  • A few users found it less effective than other brands, leading to returns in some cases.
Buy on Amazon:)
Buy on Amazon

Armour Etch Glass Etching Cream:


  • Highly rated for its effectiveness with a 4.8-star rating.
  • Known for its long-lasting quality, even when not used frequently.
  • Users report successful removal of reflective coatings from plastic lenses, restoring clarity.
  • Can create permanent etched designs on windows and is dishwasher-safe.
  • Easy-to-follow instructions and relatively short etching times for quick results.

  • Cons:

  • Not suitable for glass eyeglasses and may cause damage.
  • Users must be cautious about not swirling the cream and follow specific application guidelines to avoid minute scratches.
  • Price may be considered high by some customers.
  • Smallest size available might not be cost-effective for all users.
Buy on Amazon now:)

Buy on Amazon

In summary, Martha Stewart Etching Cream is appreciated for its versatility but may have inconsistent results on certain surfaces. 

On the other hand, Armour Etch Glass Etching Cream is highly rated for its effectiveness and long shelf life, making it a preferred choice for many users, especially for plastic lenses. 

However, it should be used with caution on the right surfaces to avoid any damage. Your choice should depend on your specific project needs and preferences.

Here some more detail about these products, lets start with Martha Stewart Etching Cream

Martha Stewart Etching Cream

My Experience with Martha Stewart Etching Cream

As a passionate DIY enthusiast, I'm always on the lookout for new and exciting craft supplies. Recently, I embarked on a glass etching project, and my search for the perfect etching cream led me to Martha Stewart Etching Cream. 

With a 4.3-star rating and intriguing promises of professional-quality etching, I was eager to put it to the test. Here, I'll share my firsthand experience with this product, highlighting its key features, pros, and cons.

Ease of Use:

One of the standout features of Martha Stewart Etching Cream is its simplicity of use. The instructions are straightforward – brush it on, wait for the magic to happen, and rinse with water. 

For someone like me, who doesn't have extensive experience with glass etching, this was a relief. The cream's consistency is thick enough to avoid dripping, which I found crucial for achieving clean and precise results.


This etching cream is touted as versatile, and it did not disappoint. I used it on glassware, mirrors, and glazed ceramics, and it performed admirably on most surfaces. It's a handy product for creating personalized gifts or adding a unique touch to everyday items like glassware or decorative mirrors.

Cleaning Convenience:

After etching, cleanup was a breeze. A simple wash with soap and water removed any residual cream, leaving me with beautifully etched surfaces and a mess-free workspace. The convenience of this feature cannot be overstated, especially for those of us who value efficiency in our creative endeavors.

Gift-Making Delight:

One of the things I appreciated most about Martha Stewart Etching Cream was its suitability for crafting personalized gifts. 

I created etched glasses for Christmas, and the cream allowed me to achieve even coverage without unsightly splotches. It's an excellent choice if you enjoy crafting heartfelt presents for friends and family.

Comparison to Other Brands:

During my glass etching journey, I couldn't help but compare Martha Stewart Etching Cream to other products I'd tried, including Armour Etch. Some users reported issues with old glass dishes, which I also encountered. 

It seems that the cream's effectiveness might vary based on the hardness of the glass. In this regard, Armour Etch, which I'd used previously and found to be runny and inconsistent, fell short. Martha Stewart's cream, in contrast, managed to impress with its ability to provide better results.

However, it's worth noting that individual experiences with etching creams can differ. What works perfectly for one project might not yield the same results for another. Therefore, while Martha Stewart Etching Cream outperformed my expectations, it's essential to consider the specific requirements of your project.

Not Without Its Flaws:

Despite its many positives, Martha Stewart Etching Cream is not flawless. Some users, including myself, encountered issues with blotchy results and uneven etching. While it worked beautifully on some surfaces, it fell short on others. 

Additionally, a few reviewers mentioned that the cream didn't perform as well as expected on old glass dishes, which could be a potential limitation.

Comparison with Competitors:

One recurring theme in the reviews I read was a comparison between Martha Stewart Etching Cream and Armour Etch Glass Etching Cream. Users who had experienced both products often preferred Martha Stewart's offering. 

They praised its thickness, lack of dripping, and better overall coverage. This sentiment aligned with my experience, as Martha Stewart Etching Cream exhibited these qualities, making it a more user-friendly choice.

Lasting Value:

One notable aspect of Martha Stewart Etching Cream is that it provides lasting value. The jar I purchased was sizeable, and I anticipate it will last me for numerous projects

This long-lasting quality could make it a cost-effective choice in the long run, especially if you frequently engage in glass etching endeavors.

Final words:

In nutshell, Martha Stewart Etching Cream is a promising addition to any DIY enthusiast's craft arsenal. Its ease of use, versatility, and cleaning convenience make it a reliable choice for a wide range of projects. 

While it may not be flawless and might not perform optimally on all surfaces, it certainly exceeded my expectations, especially when compared to some competitors like Armour Etch. 

For those looking to embark on glass etching adventures or create personalized gifts, Martha Stewart Etching Cream is a worthy contender to consider. 

However, always remember that the effectiveness of any etching cream can vary depending on the specific materials and surfaces you're working with, so some experimentation may be necessary to achieve the best results for your unique projects.

Now lets talk about Armour Etch Glass Etching Cream

Armour Etch Glass Etching Cream

A Crystal-Clear Vision: Exploring the Excellence of Armour Etch Glass Etching Cream

In the world of do-it-yourself (DIY) enthusiasts, crafting projects can vary from the simple to the intricate. Those who've ventured into glass etching know the importance of choosing the right etching cream. 

One product that has consistently earned high praise is the Armour Etch Glass Etching Cream. With a stellar 4.8-star rating, it has garnered a reputation for its effectiveness and reliability. 

This review delves into the remarkable features, pros, and cons of Armour Etch, offering a comprehensive look at why it's the preferred choice for many.

Unparalleled Longevity:

A standout feature of Armour Etch Glass Etching Cream is its ability to maintain its potency over time. As numerous crafters have noted, other brands of etching cream can lose effectiveness if left unused for extended periods. Armour Etch, however, exhibits no such issues. 

This attribute is particularly appealing for those who engage in occasional crafting, ensuring that the cream remains ready for action even after a month or more of inactivity.

Flawless Performance on Plastic Lenses:

One of the most remarkable applications of Armour Etch is its ability to rejuvenate plastic lenses. Users who've entrusted their eyeglasses to this etching cream have been astounded by the results. 

It effectively removes banged-up reflective coatings from plastic lenses, leaving them crystal clear. This is a game-changer for individuals who want to prolong the life of their eyewear or who can't afford to replace their glasses. 

It's essential to note, however, that this product should not be used on glass eyeglasses, as it may cause damage.

User-Friendly Instructions:

Armour Etch provides straightforward and easy-to-follow instructions. Users have found that leaving the cream on for a duration of 6 to 8 minutes yields the best results. 

Rinsing with warm water is recommended, and a common mistake to avoid is wiping with a napkin, which could lead to scratches on the treated surface. Many users have discovered that a cotton t-shirt works best for this purpose. 

The user-friendly instructions make it accessible to both beginners and experienced crafters.

Efficiency and Quick Results:

Crafting often involves time-sensitive projects, and Armour Etch caters to this need. The relatively short etching time of 6 to 8 minutes ensures that you can achieve your desired results quickly. 

However, some users have reported letting it sit for around 30 minutes to achieve a more frosted look when the recommended time didn't seem sufficient. This flexibility in application time makes it adaptable to various creative needs.

Preservation of UV Coating:

Another surprising benefit of Armour Etch is its ability to preserve the UV coating on prescription lenses. Some users, who unknowingly used isopropyl alcohol-based lens cleaners, experienced issues with their coating breaking down and causing blurriness. 

Armour Etch effectively removes the compromised coating, leaving users with clear and unimpaired vision. This revelation could be particularly valuable for those who have unknowingly damaged their eyeglasses' coatings.

Lasting Value and Cost Consideration:

While some users may find the price of Armour Etch to be relatively high, it's essential to consider the lasting value it offers. Crafters have found that a little goes a long way, and even the smallest 2.8oz jar can cover numerous projects. 

When comparing this product's effectiveness to its cost, it becomes apparent that it provides excellent value in the long run, especially for those who engage in glass etching regularly.

Positive User Experiences:

A common thread in reviews of Armour Etch Glass Etching Cream is the consistently positive user experiences. Many individuals have reported using this product multiple times and have always been satisfied with the results. 

Whether it's etching glass bottles for decorative accents or tackling more substantial projects, Armour Etch consistently delivers on its promises. This dependability is one of the key reasons it maintains its high rating.

Notable Cons:

While Armour Etch Glass Etching Cream boasts numerous advantages, it's essential to acknowledge its limitations. One of the primary drawbacks is that it's not suitable for use on glass eyeglasses. Attempting to use it on glass lenses may result in damage, so users must exercise caution. 

Additionally, some users have found the price to be relatively high compared to other options, although the product's lasting value offsets this concern for many.

Incomparable Versatility:

Armour Etch shines in its versatility. It's not limited to one type of project or surface. Whether you're crafting personalized gifts, restoring the clarity of plastic lenses, or etching glassware, this product rises to the occasion. 

Its ability to adapt to various creative needs sets it apart and makes it a valuable addition to any DIY toolkit.

Dishwasher-Safe Designs:

Another significant advantage of Armour Etch is its ability to create permanent etched designs on windows that are dishwasher-safe. This feature ensures that your creative endeavors stand the test of time and maintain their quality even after repeated use and washing.

In summary, Armour Etch Glass Etching Cream stands as a testament to the excellence achievable in the world of DIY crafting supplies. Its unparalleled longevity, remarkable performance on plastic lenses, and user-friendly instructions make it a top choice for creative enthusiasts. 

The preservation of UV coatings on eyeglasses and its cost-effective value further solidify its position as a preferred product. 

While it's crucial to be mindful of its limitations, particularly when working with glass eyeglasses, Armour Etch continues to earn accolades for its versatility, efficiency, and positive user experiences. 

Whether you're a seasoned crafter or a newcomer to glass etching, Armour Etch is undoubtedly a worthy investment for your crafting projects.

About TOP Experts A2Z - TEAZ

Your go-to destination for expert reviews and informed guidance across a vast array of products, ensuring every purchase is a confident step towards satisfaction and excellence. AS AN AMAZON ASSOCIATE TEAZ MAY EARN FROM QUALIFYING PURCHASES.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Start typing and press Enter to search